“O vainglorious pain”/ O ceaseless rain!… and more

There are few competitors (only Hou Hsiao-Hsien) for perpetrating very long immobile shots, frequently without any of the characters in or staying in the frame, of Tsai Ming-Liang movies. I am mystified by the critical praise (and international prizes, including Golden Horses for director and actor and a Venice Film Festival special Jury Prize and a Golden Mouse) he has accrued, especially for the excruciating (not just slow) “Jiao you” (Stray Dogs, 2013), which has Tsai’s muse, Lee Kang-Sheng shuffling along on the margins of Taipei as a homeless (squatter) alcoholic who holds up an advertising sign in the constant rain at a Taipei inersection and has two children (the actor’s real-life nephew and niece) who mostly have to fend for themselves. There is no narrative and no payoff of long, long, long shots by an immobile camera of rainy riverbank (Tsia’s cinematic universe has always been notably soggy) or contemplating a charcoal landscape mural for thirteen mute minutes. Tsai is bored with making movies and has said this may be his last. It certainly shows and shares his boredom.


Chen Kaige’s (2012) “Sousuo” (Caught in the Web) has rapid cuts and a complex narrative. It is unlike other Chen movies (centering on a video clip going viral), but is intriguing and watchable and even touching in the end, with considerable humor along the way.



Koreeda Horikazu’s (20013) “Soshite chichi ni naru” (Like Father, Like Son) is intermediate in scene length, and unsurprisingly touching as a hard-driving businessman (Fukuyama Masaharu) and his wife (Ono Machiko) find that their six-year-old son was switched in the hospital with the son of a fairly feckless (at least unambitious) but warm small-town shop owner (Lily Frnky) and his wife (Maki Yôko). After some trial stays with their biological parents, a switch is made. As in “The Other Son,” in which there is a vaster gap between the families, the boys bond with each other.

As usual in Koreeda movies (e.g., I Wish, Nobody Knows) the children are both captivating and resilient, puzzling the adults to varying degrees. That both sons prefer love to money is not a surprise.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s